From local favorites to national honors, Holy Cow has been recognized for bold flavors, creativity, and consistency. Here’s a look at some of the awards we’ve earned along the way.

Awards & Recognition

North American Ice Cream Association

2024 - “Grand Master Ice Cream Maker”

2024 - “Northeast Region Flavor of the Year” (Pistachio Baklava)

2023 - “Northeast Region Flavor of the Year” (Jackpot)

2022 - “Flavor of the Year” (Ritzy AF)

2022 - “Flavor of the Year” - 3rd Place (Eazy Peazy)

2021 - “Non-Dairy Flavor of the Year” - 2nd Place (Vegan Lemon Cookie)

2019 - “Best New Flavor” - Honorable Mention (The Charleston)

Northshore Magazine - Best of Northshore

2025 - Ice Cream - Editor + Reader's Choice

2024 - Ice Cream - Reader's Choice

2023 - Ice Cream - Editor + Reader's Choice

2022 - Ice Cream - Editor's Choice