2024 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Roasted pistachio butter ice cream loaded with house-made pistachio baklava pieces Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts

Brown butter ice cream loaded with house-made cornbread pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Fruity Pebbles steeped ice cream mixed with colorful cereal marshmallows. Colored with all natural Blue Spirulina! Contains: Dairy & Soy

National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate Contains: Dairy

Iced coffee ice cream. Extra Cream. Extra Sugar. Contains: Dairy

Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy

Brown sugar buttercream ice cream with housemade oatmeal cream pie chunks Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Strawberry Nesquik ice cream loaded with frosted animal crackers & Funfetti cake Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Vanilla bean custard ice cream loaded with chunks of house-made pastel de nata & cinnamon salted caramel Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

National Award-Winning Strawberry: NAICA Red Ribbon Rich strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction Contains: Dairy

National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Classic, creamy vanilla ice cream made with all natural Madagascar Vanilla Contains: Dairy

Vegan coconut ice cream loaded with GLUTEN FREE Oreos Contains: Coconut & Soy

Coconut based cookie butter ice cream loaded with speculoos cookies Contains: Coconut, Gluten & Soy

Coconut based Ube ice cream loaded with house-made vegan chocolate hazelnut bark Contains: Coconut & Hazelnut

Vegan coconut ice cream with "bloody" cherry swirl, toasted almond chocolate bark & candied cherries Contains: Coconut, Almond & Soy

2oz container of cherries *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of chocolate sprinkles *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of crushed Oreo pieces *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of premium Callebaut chocolate chips *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of mini M&Ms *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of peanuts *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of rainbow sprinkles *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of walnuts *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of caramel *served in a compostable container*

2oz container of Reese’s Natural peanut butter sauce *served in a compostable container*

Our national award-winning vanilla ice cream sandwiched between house-made chocolate chip cookies and rolled in mini chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

A Holy Cow Pint Pass entitles the holder to 12 pints. You simply present the Pass in-person at any of our locations and redeem for one or more pints whenever you'd like. It's like getting two free pints! *1 Reserve pint redemption per Pass*

Sip in style with your go-everywhere Holy Cow tumbler — and enjoy a sweet perk every time you stop in. Bring in your Holy Tumbler anytime to unlock Stuff Your Stanley for $12. Reusable, refillable, and always a good idea. Perk valid in-shop only. Tumbler must be present and clean to redeem.

Two custom charms to collect and wear with pride! Deck out your Crocs, sandals, bags, and attire with these delicious pieces of flare.

5 x 3.3 inch Bumper Sticker

Inspired by our lemon curd ice cream loaded with house-made lemon bars, this scented candle will rejuvenate your spirit with its bold, refreshing fragrance. Soy based candle made in collaboration with French Press Candle Co.