Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe Peabody
86 Andover Street, Peabody, MA
Novelties
Ice Cream Sandwiches

Old Fashioned
Our national award-winning vanilla ice cream sandwiched between house-made chocolate chip cookies and rolled in mini chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$9.50
Pup Cups
Pup Cup
Coconut based peanut butter ice cream!$3.99
Ice Cream
Pints

Pistachio Baklava
2024 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Roasted pistachio butter ice cream loaded with house-made pistachio baklava pieces Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts$10.99
Apple Cider Donut (Collab w/ Downeast Cider)
Vanilla ice cream loaded with house-made cider donuts & cider infused salted caramel Donuts & Caramel made with Downeast cider donut reduction *contains no alcohol Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Apple Pie
Apple cinnamon ice cream loaded with chunks of apple & house-made graham cracker crust & cinnamon infused salted caramel Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Brown Butter Cornbread
Brown butter ice cream loaded with house-made cornbread pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Cereal Milk
Fruity Pebbles steeped ice cream mixed with colorful cereal marshmallows. Colored with all natural Blue Spirulina! Contains: Dairy & Soy$10.99
Chocolate
National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate Contains: Dairy$10.99
Coffee - "Xtra Xtra"
Iced coffee ice cream. Extra Cream. Extra Sugar. Contains: Dairy$10.99
Cold Brew Oreo
Our bold cold brew based ice cream loaded up with Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Cookie Dough
Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Cookies & Cream
Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Corner Piece
Brown butter chocolate ice cream mixed with homemade crispy brownie corner pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Mintsanity
Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy$10.99
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Brown sugar buttercream ice cream with housemade oatmeal cream pie chunks Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Pastel de Nata
Vanilla bean custard ice cream loaded with chunks of house-made pastel de nata & cinnamon salted caramel Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Ritzy AF
2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (1st Place) Salted Butter Cracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Salted Caramel Brownie
Salted caramel ice cream loaded with house-made brownie pieces & salted caramel swirl Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy$10.99
Salted Peanut Butter Oreo
Salted Peanut Butter ice cream loaded with Oreos & peanut butter swirl Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts & Soy$10.99
Strawberry
National Award-Winning Strawberry: NAICA Red Ribbon Rich strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction Contains: Dairy$10.99
Vanilla
National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Classic, creamy vanilla ice cream made with all natural Madagascar Vanilla Contains: Dairy$10.99
Vegan Pints

Vegan Coconut Oreo
Vegan coconut ice cream loaded with GLUTEN FREE Oreos Contains: Coconut & Soy$12.50
Vegan Cookie Butter
Coconut based cookie butter ice cream loaded with speculoos cookies Contains: Coconut, Gluten & Soy$12.50
Add-Ons
Topping Pods

Cherries
2oz container of cherries *served in a compostable container*$0.75
Chocolate Sprinkles
2oz container of chocolate sprinkles *served in a compostable container*$1.00
Crushed Oreos
2oz container of crushed Oreo pieces *served in a compostable container*$0.75
Mini Chocolate Chips
2oz container of premium Callebaut chocolate chips *served in a compostable container*$1.50
Mini M&Ms
2oz container of mini M&Ms *served in a compostable container*$1.50
Peanuts
2oz container of peanuts *served in a compostable container*$1.00
Rainbow Sprinkles
2oz container of rainbow sprinkles *served in a compostable container*$1.00
Walnuts
2oz container of walnuts *served in a compostable container*$0.75
Sauce Pods

Caramel Sauce
2oz container of caramel *served in a compostable container*$1.75
Homemade Hot Fudge Sauce
2oz container of fudge sauce made in house *served in a compostable container*$1.75
Peanut Butter Sauce
2oz container of Reese’s Natural peanut butter sauce *served in a compostable container*$1.75
Beverages
Soft Drinks

Coke
$3.00
Diet Coke
$3.00
Orange Fanta
$3.00
Sprite
$3.00
Mexican Coke
$3.50
Coke Zero
$3.00
Water

Topo Chico Mineral Water (Twist of Lime)
$3.00
Smart Water
$3.50
Misc Drinks

Fair Life Chocolate Milk
$3.00
Bodyarmor Lyte - Peach Mango
$4.00
Bodyarmor Lyte - Blueberry Pomegranate
$4.00
Vitamin Water - Acai Blueberry Pomegranate
$3.00
Merch & More
Cow Club Exclusives

Pint Pass
A Holy Cow Pint Pass entitles the holder to 12 pints. You simply present the Pass in-person at any of our locations and redeem for one or more pints whenever you'd like. It's like getting two free pints! *1 Reserve pint redemption per Pass*$99.99
The Holy Tumbler Club
Sip in style with your go-everywhere Holy Cow tumbler — and enjoy a sweet perk every time you stop in. Bring in your Holy Tumbler anytime to unlock Stuff Your Stanley for $12. Reusable, refillable, and always a good idea. Perk valid in-shop only. Tumbler must be present and clean to redeem.$45.00
Swag
Croc Charms
Two custom charms to collect and wear with pride! Deck out your Crocs, sandals, bags, and attire with these delicious pieces of flare.$4.99
Candle - Ritzy
Inspired by our award-winning salted buttercracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz bark toffee. Take it in. That is the aroma of victory. Sweet, sweet victory. Soy based candle made in collaboration with French Press Candle Co.$19.99
Candle Bundle
Inspired by our award winning ice creams! Package includes 3 scents: Eazy Peazy Cereal Milk Ritzy AF Soy based candle made in collaboration with French Press Candle Co.$49.99

Brown Butter Cornbread
$10.99
Brown butter ice cream loaded with house-made cornbread pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy
1